Cloud StarTricky Trainers Soft & Chewy Dog Training Treats 12 oz. Bag, Peanut Butter Flavor, Grain-Free Low Calorie Behavior Aid with 310 treats

WHAT IS IN THESE THINGS?!!!! My dogs get mildly excited when I open any package. When I opened the envelope they lost their minds! They followed me around the house, wherever the baggie went. I hadn't even opened it yet! I put them on the counter, they kept walking me over to the bag. I tried to go to bed, got all snuggled in, and my well behaved sleeper jumped on my chest (only 12lbs thank goodness!). She started crying, so I followed her, where else, but to the treats...I had to put them in a freezer bag, in the cabinet so I could get some sleep! HA!Size as you would expect, price was pretty good, shopped around and this is pretty average. 3 cal, grain free, sounds good and healthy!One important factor, they DO NOT SMELL BAD! ...as some do, you know.Looking forward to letting the doggos sample some other flavors!

I like the low calories of this treat. Dogs love them as long as I pick the right flavors. I have picky eaters and they are sensitive to various tastes so the flavors really matter.

My dogs love these. They fit in the Furbo treat camera without getting stuck.

My baby loved these like there's no tomorrow.

My dog doesn't really like these. She loves the crunch tricky trainers. These smell strongly of smoke flavoring. Maybe that's what she doesn't like. They are fresh and soft, packaged well. My dog just won't eat them.

I wash my hounds faces every morning..it great when they stay still..two of these bits to praise them for following my command is so perfect..they are about the size of the eraser on a number 2 pencil..very pleased with my purchase.

I use these to train my German shepherd mix. He loved them and they were healthy, soft and a good value for the buck.

My dog loves these, and they are just the right size for a chihuahua.